A Small Hydroelectric Dam Could Be the Beginning of the End for the World's Rarest Ape - Pacific Standard

A Small Hydroelectric Dam Could Be the Beginning of the End for the World's Rarest Ape

With no more than 800 individuals left in a fragile habitat, the Tapanuli orangutan could face extinction not long after we became aware of its existence.
Author:
Publish date:
Social count:
69
A male Tapanuli orangutan in the Batang Toru forest.

A male Tapanuli orangutan in the Batang Toru forest.

Even as scientists introduced the world to a new species of orangutan in 2017—one of only seven non-human great apes alive today—they were already working to pinpoint the threats that might lead to its demise.

In a study published in the journal Current Biology, a team of scientists reports that road expansion, agricultural conversion, and a planned hydropower project could destroy more than one-quarter of the Tapanuli orangutan's existing habitat. With no more than 800 individuals, the world's rarest ape species could face extinction not long after we became aware of its existence.

"In 40 years of research, I don't think I've ever seen anything this dramatic," said William Laurance, a tropical ecologist at James Cook University in Australia and the team's leader, in a statement.

In November, a different group of researchers concluded that orangutans living in the Batang Toru region should be considered a new species, Pongo tapanuliensis. Based on the differences in their behavior, genetics, and morphology, the Tapanuli orangutan is distinct from its cousins living in the rainforests of Borneo (Pongo pygmaeus) and elsewhere in Sumatra (Pongo abelii), they argued.

Around the same time, Laurance and his colleagues had created detailed maps of the road network across northern Sumatra, including the forests of Batang Toru, part of a broader effort to map both infrastructure projects and targets for conservation across Southeast Asia. They decided to use those analyses to explore the impact the existing—and future—infrastructure developments might have on the Tapanuli orangutan.

"It just seemed like an obvious thing to do," Laurance says.

They found that planned developments pose a serious threat to this species' survival, not to mention that of other animals such as the critically endangered Sumatran tiger.

The forests that are home to the Tapanuli orangutan are split into eastern and western "blocks," along with the Lubuk Raya reserve, creating three isolated populations. What's more, about 5 percent of the remaining numbers live in the Dolok Sibual Buali reserve, linked to the western block by a sliver of forest only about 2,300 feet wide.

This corridor, as well as a sizable chunk of the eastern block of habitat, have been zoned for oil palm and other types of agriculture, putting around 14 percent of the species' total habitat in danger of development. Splitting the already-disjointed orangutan populations into smaller and smaller pieces will increase the chances of problems like inbreeding and accelerate the species' slide toward extinction, the authors write.

But the most pressing threat looming over these orangutans is a proposed 510-megawatt hydroelectric dam.

"It's right in the core habitat," Laurance said.

Based on the team's analyses, they figure the project would dramatically change 37 square miles, or about 8 percent, of the animal's range in the next four years. The dam's construction would inevitably carry with it a suite of ancillary impacts, such as the access roads that crews will build and the pathways for power lines that they'll have to carve through the forest. Such openings into the forest increase the odds that farmers will clear more land for agriculture or hunters will enter the area.

Conversely, restoring forest at the proposed site of the dam would create a few narrow corridors that could reconnect the eastern and western populations and boost the species' chances of survival, Laurance said.

Despite these concerns, the project continues to move forward. Laurance said that he received confirmation that the World Bank has decided not to help fund the $1.6-billion project, likely because of the potential environmental damage. But the Bank of China has pledged financing for the dam, and a Chinese-state-owned hydroelectric company called Sinohydro has signed on to handle its construction.

"It's only about 510 megawatts. That's not that much," said Serge Wich, a primatologist at England's Liverpool John Moores University, in an interview. "There are alternatives to get that energy."

Wich was not involved in this research, but he was a co-author of the paper announcing the new orangutan species in November.

"There is so little time to protect this species," he said. "The main value in this paper for us is that we can use it to further indicate what the main threats are and that there are still parts of their habitat need to be protected."

He urged the dam's developers and representatives of the Indonesian government "to have a sensible discussion" about alternatives for generating power in this part of Sumatra. In the same vein, a growing cadre of scientists and conservation organizations, led by groups like the Sumatran Orangutan Conservation Programme and the Sumatran Orangutan Society, are campaigning for a change in the project's course.

But if that doesn't happen, the dam would be "the beginning of the end of this species," Wich said.

He said that little beyond the "extreme conservation" approached used in shepherding Africa's mountain gorillas back from the brink of extinction, such as near-round-the-clock surveillance by armed guards, will keep the Tapanuli orangutan from disappearing forever.

"Personally, I think it would be an enormous tragedy if we would lose a species for 510 megawatts," he added. "That sounds absurd to me, but that seems [to be] where it's heading if the government and company are not willing to change their path."

Laurance and his colleagues agree, arguing in the paper that the government should protect every bit of the animal's remaining habitat without hesitation.

"It's not going to take a huge push to actually drive something like this to extinction," he said. "It is absolutely time to pull out all the stops."

This story originally appeared at the website of global conservation news service Mongabay.com. Get updates on their stories delivered to your inbox, or follow @Mongabay on Facebook, Instagram, or Twitter.

Related