It seems Democrats are much more united in their opposition to the repeal-and-replace bill than Republican members are in support of it.
By Charles Ornstein & Derek Willis
(Photo: Scott Olson/Getty Images)
Turns out that Democrats have more to say than Republicans when it comes to legislation that would repeal major parts of the Affordable Care Act, better known as Obamacare.
A ProPublica review of 576 press releases posted on the websites of representatives and senators since January 20th found that a higher proportion of Democrats have released statements criticizing the GOP bill than Republicans have backing it.
Though Republicans control both houses of Congress, many have stayed silent, at least on their websites. Senator Richard Shelby, an Alabama Republican, put out a press release March 14th about a study of red snapper in the Gulf of Mexico, but nothing on health care.
Among members of the House of Representatives, where the action is now focused, about 46 percent of Republicans have issued statements about health-care reform from the start of the Trump administration to this week. Among Democrats, 67 percent.
The dynamics are similar in the Senate, which would take up the bill if and when it passes the House. Only 35 percent of Republicans have weighed in, compared to 60 percent of Democrats and independents who caucus with them.
All told, Republicans have issued some 240 press releases about health reform; Democrats and independents at least 336. (The analysis includes statements members have posted on their websites and doesn’t include statements to reporters or on social media.) House Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wisconsin) had the most of any member, 36, four times as many as the next-highest statement-writer, Representative Diana DeGette (D-Colorado).
Moreover, Democrats are much more united in their opposition to the repeal-and-replace bill than Republican members are in support, according to our analysis.
Dr. David Blumenthal, president of the Commonwealth Fund, a health-care non-profit in New York, said that doesn’t surprise him. When the Affordable Care Act was under consideration in 2009 and 2010, Republicans were united in their opposition while Democratic support was “quite fractured,” said Blumenthal, who was the national coordinator for health information technology during the early years of the Obama administration.
Blumenthal said this dynamic is “part of the burden of governance and the opportunity of opposition.”
“When you are in the driver’s seat, as the Republican majority is at this point, you are forced to look in detail at the thing you want to try to create, and that can be sobering, whereas the opposition has a much easier time drawing lines in the sand.”
A lot can be gleaned by the words officials use — and avoid.
The Words Democrats Use
Medicaid, the joint federal-state health insurance program for the poor: The Affordable Care Act allowed states to expand Medicaid to cover millions more people living in poverty or near-poverty, including childless adults. The GOP bill would cut Medicaid spending by $880 billion over the next decade, according to the Congressional Budget Office.
About half of the press releases we analyzed, 285, mention Medicaid. And, of those, 198 came from Democrats. “42,200 individuals in our Congressional District who are covered by the ACA’s Medicaid expansion now stand to lose coverage if Washington Republicans eliminate Medicaid expansion,” wrote Representative Cheri Bustos (D-Illinois) echoing what many colleagues did by personalizing the data for her district.
When they do raise the issue, Republicans said their plan makes needed changes to Medicaid. “We also refocus Medicaid’s limited resources to the patients most in need,” said Representative Tom Rice (R-South Carolina).
Congressional Budget Office: Of the 213 statements mentioning the CBO or Congressional Budget Office, only 28 came from Republicans. Democrats mentioned the CBO in two ways: At first, they criticized Republicans for considering the bill before having the results of the CBO analysis; then Democrats held up the CBO report, also called a score, as proof that the law would roll back many of the gains made by the ACA.
“The report released today by the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office underscores that the Republican health care bill will result in millions of currently-insured Americans no longer having coverage,” wrote Representative Steve Cohen (D-Tennessee).
The few Republicans who addressed the CBO analysis, including Ryan, pointed to its conclusion that the legislation would reduce the deficit and said the GOP bill is only the first step in a multipart plan to reform the health-care system.
Trump: President Donald Trump remains a polarizing figure and Democrats are trying to tie the repeal legislation to him personally, dubbing it “Trumpcare.” Of the 216 mentions of Trump in the releases, 141 came from Democrats and independents. “Trumpcare is a great deal for insurance companies,” Representative David N. Cicilline (D-Rhode Island) wrote. “It’s a great deal for drug companies. But it’s a really bad deal for hardworking Americans.”
By contrast, Republicans who mention Trump do so in the context of working with his administration and his commitments to change health care delivery.
24,000,000: One hundred thirty-five statements mention this figure — the number of Americans projected by the CBO to lose health insurance by 2026 under the Republican proposal. Of those, only four are from Republican members. “Under Trumpcare, middle-class families will pay more for less care, and 24 million Americans may lose their coverage altogether,” wrote Representative Dan Kildee (D-Michigan).
The Words Republicans Use
Obamacare: Early on, the ACA was dubbed “Obamacare” in an attempt by Republicans to tie it to the president. Over time, Obama himself tried to co-opt the phrase to make the point that “Obama cares.” Some public polling shows that people do not know that the ACA and Obamacare are one and the same, favoring the former while opposing the latter. The term Obamacare was mentioned in 228 releases. A whopping 196 of them were by Republicans, often to emphasize the program’s negative effects. “Obamacare is collapsing under its own weight, driving up health-care costs, and limiting options for individuals and families,” wrote Representative Jackie Walorski (R-Indiana).
Choice: One of the GOP selling points about their proposal is that it lets people choose whether they want insurance and which plan to buy, freeing them from many current requirements. Of the 154 statements that mention the word “choice” or “choose,” 133 of them come from Republicans. “We are driving down costs and giving patients more choice in their health care,” Representative Michael Burgess (R-Texas), a physician, said in a statement.
One of the few Democrats to mention the word, Representative Donald Beyer (D-Virginia) wrote, “The president promised a health-care program that would ‘expand choice, increase access, lower costs, and at the same time, provide better health care.’ The bill [that] House Republicans unveiled last night does none of these things.”
Mandate: The ACA requires that employers provide coverage to their workers and that Americans be covered by health insurance — or pay a penalty. The so-called employer and individual mandates are unpopular with Republicans because they are perceived as requiring people to buy health insurance they may not want or need. Of the 111 releases that mentioned mandates, 93 were by Republicans. “We are providing a more consumer focused marketplace, not a government mandate with burdensome taxes,” wrote Representative John Carter (R-Texas).
Relief: GOP lawmakers say their legislation provides relief from the requirements of the ACA. Of the 81 statements that use this word, 78 are from Republicans. “For years, Nebraskans have called on us to provide relief from Obamacare’s rising premiums and dwindling choices,” said Representative Adrian Smith (R-Nebraska). “Too many Americans have been hurt by this failing law, and now we finally have the opportunity to reset our health-care system.”