Trump Supporters Are More Likely to Oppose Public Policies When They Think About Black People

Author:
Publish date:

That’s the finding of a new study by two political scientists.

By Lisa Wade

63c83-1vkk_56e5rctarhhmavj7eg

Donald Trump greets supporters after his rally at Ladd-Peebles Stadium on August 21st, 2015, in Mobile, Alabama. (Photo: Mark Wallheiser/Getty Images)

Are some Donald Trump supporters’ political views motivated by race?

One way to find out is to see whether the typical Trump supporter is less likely to support policies when they are subtly influenced to think that they are helping black versus white people. This was the root of a study by political scientists Christopher Federico, Matthew Luttig, and Howard Lavine.

Prior to the election, they asked 746 white respondents to complete an Internet survey. Each person was randomly assigned to see one of two pictures at the beginning of the survey: a white man standing next to a foreclosure sign or the exact same photograph featuring a black man. Respondents were also asked whether they supported Trump. (Non-white people were left out of the analysis because there were too few Trump supporters among them to run meaningful comparative statistics.)

The first graph shows that white Trump supporters were eight percentage points more likely to oppose mortgage relief if they had seen a “black cue” (the photo featuring a black man) than a “white cue.” The opposite was true for white Trump opponents.

957ba-00sfmeb168g0qzvq3

When asked if they were “somewhat angry” about the assistance, the same pattern held:

11a57-08kenrps43nydldt9

And likewise when asked if the beneficiaries of mortgage assistance were at least “somewhat to blame” for their situation:

9b06f-0cnntrm_tww4fnhln

Findings held when the researchers controlled for possible confounding variables.

These findings aren’t particularly surprising. Others have also found that priming respondents to think of black people tends to make them tougher on crime and advocate for less generous social programs, like in this study on attitudes toward California’s three-strikes law. What’s new here is the difference between Trump supporters and opponents. For opponents of Trump, priming made them more sympathetic toward mortgage holders; for supporters, priming made them less. This speaks to a real divide among Americans. Some of us feel real hostility toward African Americans. Others definitely do not.

This story originally appeared on Sociological Images, a Pacific Standard partner site, as “‘Trump Supporters Especially Oppose Public Policies When Cued to Think About Black People.”

Related